By the way ... I wrote the entry on the Quorum Clause in The Heritage Guide to the Constitution (3d). See Seth Barrett Tillman, Essay No. 25, Quorum Clause, in The Heritage Guide to the Constitution (Josh Blackman & John Malcolm eds., 3d ed. 2025), <https://ssrn.com/abstract=4512557>, <https://constitution.heritage.org/essays/a1-s5-c1-b/>. I think your and your colleagues’ en banc decision understood the clause correctly—but I think on a fine point, you (collectively) erred. See id. at 77–78 (discussing Senate quorum rule in the second session of the First Congress). To put it another way, the historical rule has been, contra John B Williams’ law review article, that the Quorum Clause requires the presence of a majority of all actual or seated members (recognized as such post-organization), not a majority of all members-elect, and not a majority of all authorized members (elected or not). When a seated member died, resigned, or was removed—the quorum could be adjusted downwards if the house had information supporting the loss of the member. I have an older, more theoretical, discussion of the Quorum Clause here: Letter from Seth Barrett Tillman to Professor Anonymous, The Quorum Clause (July 2, 2014), <http://ssrn.com/abstract=2462012>. It is very short.
As for English/British/UK practice ... the House of Lords, although it had allowed proxy voting, did not allow (as far as I know) using proxies to establish a quorum. And it would have made no sense to do so. During the 18th century the Lords’ quorum was, I believe, three members—and that included the Lord Chancellor/Lord Speaker/Lord Deputy Speaker in the chair. It was not until the late 19th century that the House of Lords established, by rule, a quorum of 30—and that 30-member rule applied only in limited circumstances, with the default otherwise remaining three members (including the presiding officer).
The Federalist Papers had several errors and oddities relating to quorums and house-size. I talk about those problems here. See Seth Barrett Tillman, The Federalist Papers as Reliable Historical Source Material for Constitutional Interpretation, 105 W. Va. L. Rev. 601 (2003), <ssrn.com/abstract=422700>. See pages 603–04, 605–09, 612–13.
Seth
Seth Barrett Tillman, ‘A Letter to a Judge,’ New Reform Club (Nov. 22, 2026, 10:05 AM), <https://reformclub.blogspot.com/2026/11/a-letter-to-judge.html>;
No comments:
Post a Comment