are you now or have you ever...

Sunday, July 31, 2016

Letter to the Editor: Responding to Robert Fisk’s "To understand the Islamist beheading of a French priest ...."

The Independent (London)
Letter to the Editor

Re:   Responding to Robert Fisk’s To understand the Islamist beheading of a French priest, we must remember what happened 20 years earlier (July 27, 2016),                                  

Robert Fisk wrote:

The Algerian civil war—between a brutal Islamist army and the equally savage Algerian army which had fatally cancelled elections which Islamists would have won in 1992—had by 1996 already reached Syrian proportions .... It was inevitable that the killers from the GIA, the Islamic Armed Group, would turn upon all foreigners—and that also meant priests and bishops. (emphasis added)

It is not “inevitable” in any civil war—no matter how brutal—that one side murder foreigners. Certainly, the GIA’s murdering foreigners—even during the brutal Algerian civil war—was not “inevitable”. It was a choice; it was the wrong choice. The people who carried out such atrocities were not lawful military combatants; they were criminals, pure and simple. The fact that Fisk argues otherwise is just another example how Western journalists lower the ethical bar when it comes to any crime perpetrated in the Third World—particularly when the crime is perpetrated by extremists in the name of Islam.

Seth Barrett Tillman

Twitter: (@SethBTillman) 


Cruising Troll said...

Well, don't forget, that was written by the gent who gifted the world with FISKING. As such, it's accuracy, logic, and quality are all as expected.

Tamanna Farhana said...

Strategies on how to write a medical school personal statement that will make you stand out from the crowded field of applicants and get you admitted to medical school. See more personal statement for pa school

Blogger said...

Did you know that you can shorten your long urls with Shortest and get money from every visit to your shortened urls.