Everything you say can and will be used against you.

Tuesday, May 21, 2019

General George Washington and the Bank of England

There is substantial evidence to support the inference that Washington, for one, did not view “private business pursuits . . . with foreign state-chartered trading companies” as emoluments. [DC & MD v. TrumpCiv. A. No. 17-cv-1154-EGS, at *23 & *27 (D.D.C. Apr. 30, 2019) (Sullivan, J.)] During the Revolutionary War, George Washington owned stock in, and received dividends from, the Bank of England.[1] This foreign corporation received its charter by operation of an act of the English Parliament: the Tonnage Act of 1694.[2] The Bank of England, which was analogous to the first Bank of the United States,[3] served as the private banker for the British Exchequer.[4] More importantly, the Bank of England was analogous to the foreign government “instrumentalit[ies]” that Plaintiffs allege Trump-affiliated commercial entities are doing business with.[5]
At the relevant times, the Articles of Confederation governed our young republic. That charter included a Foreign Emoluments Clause, which provided “[N]or shall any person holding any office of profit or trust under the United States, or any of them [i.e., any State], accept of any present, emolument, office or title of any kind whatever from any King, Prince or foreign State . . . .”[6] Furthermore, the Continental Congress had chosen Washington as the commander-in-chief of the nation’s armed forces. As an appointed military officer, he held an “office . . . under the United States,” and could not “accept of any . . . emolument” from a “foreign State.”
If the Court’s analysis were correct, then General Washington would not have been permitted to accept distributions—a “profit, gain, or advantage”—from the Bank of England, a “foreign state-chartered . . . company.” [DC & MD v. TrumpCiv. A. No. 17-cv-1154-EGS, at *23 & *27 (D.D.C. Apr. 30, 2019) (Sullivan, J.)] But he did. Nor was Washington a passive beneficiary of bank-related benefits. For example, throughout the Revolution, Washington’s personal London representatives, at his instructions, transferred such monies out of the Bank of England, to make payments to his creditors.[7] Thus Washington was not a mere passive recipient of automatic distributions; rather, he made timely use of sophisticated foreign commercial agents who actively “accept[ed]” dividend income on his behalf during the war. After peace was made, Washington took action to close the account and to repatriate the funds from the Bank of England account.[8]
Amici know of no evidence that any contemporaries or that any subsequent historians or legal scholars suggested that these transactions violated established law. This absence of debate reaffirms DOJ’s position that “substantial ground for difference of opinion” exists with respect to how Washington, and those in the early Republic, understood the term emolument. The better reading is that during the Founding era, an emolument was tied to lawfully authorized office-related or employment-related compensation.




[1] See Bryan Jones, The Farming Game 151 (1982); Eugene E. Prussing, George Washington, Captain of Industry/The Bank of England Stock—The Bank of the United States, 70(5) Scribner’s Mag. 549, 554, 556–57 (Nov. 1921); see also Sol Bloom, Our Heritage: George Washington and the Establishment of the American Union 210 (1944); Thomas Bayard McCabe, Central Banking’s Role in Our Free Enterprise Society 17 (1951).
[2] Robert J. Reinstein, The Limits of Congressional Power, 89 Temp. L. Rev. 1, 11 n.53 (2016).
[3] See Ron Chernow, Alexander Hamilton 347 (2004).
[4] See Our History, Bank of England, https://perma.cc/B7FQ-Y5QA; see also Robert E. Wright, The Wealth of Nations Rediscovered 13 (2002).
[5] See Plaintiffs’ Amend. Compl., ECF No. 14, at ¶¶ 56, 59, 62, 65, Part VI/Prayer For Relief.
[6] Articles of Confederation of 1781, art. VI, para. 1. Textually, the Confederation provision was very similar to the Foreign Emoluments Clause now in force under the United States Constitution. Accord U.S. Const. art. I, § 9, cl. 8 (“[N]o Person holding any Office of Profit or Trust under them [i.e., the United States], shall, without the Consent of the Congress, accept of any present, Emolument, Office, or Title, of any kind whatever, from any King, Prince, or foreign State.”).
[7] See Bloom, supra note 1, at 210; Letter from George Washington to Robert Cary & Co (May 1, 1759), Founders Online, https://tinyurl.com/yy3arfaf.
[8] See Bloom, supra note 1, at 210; Prussing, supra note 6, at 556. 


The above is an extract from my just-filed amicus brief: 
Brief of Scholar Seth Barrett Tillman and Judicial Education Project as Amici Curiae in Support of the Defendant’s Supplemental Brief in Support of his Motion Pursuant to 28 U.S.C. § 1292(b) for Certification of the Court’s Denial of Motion to Dismiss and Defendant’s Motion to the Stay, Senator Richard Blumenthal v. Donald J. Trump, in his official capacity as President of the United States of America, Civ. A. No. 1:17-cv-01154-EGS (D.D.C. May 21, 2019) (Sullivan, J.), ECF No. 73-1, ____ WL _______, 2019 U.S. Dist. Ct. Briefs LEXIS __, <https://ssrn.com/abstract=3381838>. 


Seth Barrett Tillman, General George Washington and the Bank of England, New Reform Club (May 21, 2019, 4:05 PM), <https://reformclub.blogspot.com/2019/05/general-george-washington-and-bank-of.html>. 

Welcome Instapundit and ChicagoBoyz readers.




Have a look around New Reform Clubmy co-bloggers do good work!


7 comments:

Anonymous said...

If staying at the Trump Hotel is an emolument, I don't see how a foreign entity purchasing one (or more) of Obama's books isn't as well.

Seamus said...

But the Bank of England at that time was a privately held entity (as the fact that Washington held stock in it should illustrate), not part of the British government. (It wasn't nationalized--or should I say nationalised--until 1946.)

Seth Barrett Tillman said...

I responded inline in square brackets. Seth

Ella Queen said...

I am so happy I got my loan from Mrs Kayla Abubaker now my life is back to normal, and my business is going smoothly thanks be to Mrs Kayla Abubaker you can also contact him if you need a loan today? Email him via: ( financierlibertycapitals@gmail.com )

Humphrey Peterson said...

GET YOUR BLANK ATM AND CREDIT CARD AT AFFORDABLE PRICE.....

We sell this cards to all our customers and interested buyers worldwide, the card has a daily withdrawal limit of $5000 and up to $50,000 spending limit in stores and unlimited on POS. *email blankatm988@gmail.com* you can also call or whatsapp us Contact us today for more enlightenment +44(7440495540.

*BEWARE OF SCAMMERS AND FAKE HACKERS IMPERSONATING US BUT THEY ARE NOT FROM US CONTACT US ONLY VIA THIS CONTACT * WE ARE REAL AND LEGIT...........2019 FUNDS/FORGET ABOUT GETTING A LOAN *email blankatm988@gmail.com, OR +447440495540, (WHATSAPP ONLY).

CONTACT US NOW AND BE HAPPY FOREVER, WE OPERATE ONLY TO ASSIST THE POOR AND HOPELESS WORLDWIDE TO LIVE A GOOD LIFE AND BECOME RICH FAMILY, AND BE ABLE TO
PAY THEIR DEPT AND START A GOOD BUSINESS OF ANY AMOUNT, THIS IS A DREAM COMES TRUE TO THE POOR AROUND THE WORLD.

NOTE: this will only cost a little charge for the preparation and the shipment of the card to your various countries, Thank you.

mr smith said...

Are You A Business Man Or Woman? Are You In Any Financial Mess Or Do You Need funds To Start Up Your Own Business? Do You Need A Loan To Start A Nice Small Scale And Medium Business?
Do You Have A Low Credit Score And You Are Finding It Hard To Obtain Capital Loan From Local Banks And Other Financial Institutes?. - Intermediaries / Consultants / Brokers Are Welcome To Bring Their Clients And Are 100% Protected. Interested Parties Should Contact Us For More Information
Through Via E-mail: quickloan9888@gmail.com.

I will Like To Inform You That Our Main Goals Are To Help Companies And Entrepreneurs Raise Their Business To better Heights By Investing, Consulting And Raising Capital Without Bank Lending. We Are Qualified In All Aspects Of Financing, Banks And Asset Based Lending. We Have The Ability To Handle All Aspects Of The Financial Needs And Challenges Of Our Clients, Including; Interested Parties or persons Should Contact Us For More Information.
Through Via E-mail: quickloan9888@gmail.com,

WE OFFER ALL KIND OF LOANS - APPLY FOR AFFORDABLE LOANS.


*BEWARE OF SCAMMERS AND FAKE HACKERS IMPERSONATING US BUT THEY ARE NOT FROM
US CONTACT US ONLY VIA THIS CONTACT *
WE ARE REAL AND LEGIT.
Through Via E-mail: quickloan9888@gmail.com,

SEND US YOUR DETAILS THROUGH OUR EMAIL OR WHATSAPP FOR THE PROCCESSING OF YOUR LOAN, THANK YOU:
- Your full Name:
- Loan amount needed:
- Loan Duration:
- Purpose of loan:
- City / Country:
- Telephone:
- How Did You Hear About Us:

NOTE: This loan requires little charges for the processing and trust from our customers worldwide...we have change many lifes and willing to do more, contact us through our office email and somebody will attend to you fast...thank you.

Unknown said...
This comment has been removed by a blog administrator.