Mensch tracht, un Gott lacht

Wednesday, November 21, 2018

An Open Letter to Professor John Yoo


John,

There’s only been one time in the history of the United States that a president defied an order from the Supreme Court. That was Ex Parte Merryman, at the beginning of the Civil War. Lincoln refused an order from the court to release a Confederate prisoner because the military had exceeded its constitutional authority.
Glen Martin, Showdown: John Yoo on Trump, Kavanaugh, and Constitutional Crisis, California Magazine (Sept. 24, 2018, 4:33 PM), https://alumni.berkeley.edu/california-magazine/just-in/2018-09-24/showdown-john-yoo-trump-kavanaugh-and-constitutional-crisis.

By now, you must know that I have consistently written against the standard narrative on Merryman since 2015, and in print, since 2016. I wrote an article opposing this point of view in Chapman Law Review. You were offered an opportunity to respond—which (I believe) you declined. Isn’t it time—long past time—to give up on the standard narrative on Merryman—or, to address my criticism of that narrative. I find your continued willingness to promote the standard narrative—absent any explanation defending it—anti-intellectual.

Even at this late juncture, I am reasonably confident that if you approached the student editors at Chapman, they would offer you pages to address my critique of the standard narrative and my critique of your prior publications.

For your convenience, I note that I have 3 publications on Merryman. They include:
[1] Seth Barrett Tillman, Ex parte Merryman: Myth, History, and Scholarship, 224 Mil. L. Rev. 481 (2016) (peer reviewed), http://ssrn.com/abstract=2646888;
[2] Seth Barrett Tillman, Merryman Redux: A Response to Professor John Yoo, 22(1) Chap. L. Rev. ___ (forthcoming circa Mar. 2019), https://ssrn.com/abstract=3213353; and,
[3] Seth Barrett Tillman, Canonical Cases and Other Quodlibets: A Response to Professor Fallon, 97 Tex. L. Rev. Online ___ (forthcoming circa Nov.-Dec. 2018), http://ssrn.com/abstract=3246598. 
Sincerely,

Seth

Seth Barrett Tillman, An Open Letter to Professor John Yoo, New Reform Club (Nov. 21, 2018, 5:45 AM), 



No comments: