"There are only two ways of telling the complete truth—anonymously and posthumously."Thomas Sowell

Tuesday, August 22, 2006

People on a Plane—with Snakes

The box office performance of a "high concept" film such as Snakes on a Plane is typically based not on the cleverness of the concept but on whether there is actually a good movie in it. Die Hard and Speed, for example, had characters we could care about, and the films put them in situations where they had interesting choices to make. Those that don't have these things usually fall off at the box office even if they get a good opening weekend.

Samuel L. Jackson in "Snakes on a Plane"

Interestingly, the least entertaining and involving parts of Snakes on a Plane are the two big action scenes in which the serpents attack the passengers on the plane. The snakes operate in a riidiculously implausible manner, even if we accept the filmmakers' premise that pheromones released on the plane would make the creatures more aggressive. These snakes are much more than "more aggressive"; they're positively malevolent and volitional. That's not at all believable—and it's not the slightest bit necessary, for the film is interesting enough without sci-fi snakes.

The first 40 minutes of the picture are devoted to scenes setting the stage for the big action sequences. The central conceit is that a young man who witnessed a murder by a powerful gangster in Hawaii consents to testify against the killer and is duly to be flown to Los Angeles to appear in court. That leads to the scheme to release hundreds of snakes on the plane and cause it to crash. OK, better plans have been devised in this world, but we'll let it go, shall we?

Poster for Snakes on a Plane

After all, what really makes a high-concept thriller successful is how the characters react to the situation, and especially the need for them to show courage, honor, and other good character traits. Snakes on a Plane has plenty of that, with some characters acting honorably, others meanly, and others developing better character through the course of the story. What is most pleasing is that the characters actually manage to surprise us just a little bit once in a while. The film has a solid performance by Samuel L. Jackson at its center, and it has the right amount of humor, meaning not too much. Snakes on a Plane also has enough action-film cliches to choke an anaconda, but the filmmakers' willingness to let us see human character in action makes it worth seeing.

From Karnick on Culture.


James Elliott said...

I will never see this film. I'd like to say it was because I am above such claptrap. But really, it's just that snakes are effing scary.

Tom Van Dyke said...

Hehe, JE.

The perfect Hollywood pitch session, which could not only be made in an elevator ride between floors, but between penises passing in the night at adjoining urinals at the Viper Club:

"Snakes. On a plane."

"Cool, dude. Sold."

Kathy Hutchins said...

The producers of our local Fox channel's news program have a bizarre tic: they try at least once during each program to do a real-world tie-in to some current TV program or movie. Thus, every Tuesday we get some local unfortunate with a baffling medical problem as a "House" tie-in, etc. Last night they chose to marry the "dimwit releases rattlesnakes in a Snakes on a Plane showing" story to a story about a dramatic rise in copperhead bites in the metro area suburbs and exurbs. Now not only am I too scared to go to the movies, I'm too scared to cut the grass in my orchard. Damn mainstream media.

James Elliott said...

I laughed my ass off when I read about those pranksters releasing rattlesnakes at a SoaP showing. My coworkers thought I was having an epileptic fit or something.

tbmbuzz said...

I've seen several snake movies, but the one that impressed me the most many years ago does not appear on any Top 10 lists. It was about a black mamba (I can't think of a scarier snake!) that was loose on a ship. The movie is 1970's or 1980's vintage, called Hiss or Sssss or something like that, and the bad guy is played by a blond Swedish-looking character actor with thick lips who was a familiar face in TV/movies at the time (he gets the snake down his pants at the end). Anyone know the name of this flick?

The Classic Liberal Anonymous said...

Anyone know the name of this flick?


The Classic Liberal Anonymous said...

Maybe Ssssss (not sure about the number of S's).

Look here

tbmbuzz said...

'Venom', that's the one! With Klaus Kinski, Oliver Reed and Susan George...