"There are only two ways of telling the complete truth—anonymously and posthumously."Thomas Sowell

Monday, July 31, 2006

Religion in a Sitcom

Sunny in Philly promo shotThose who complain that Hollywood seldom depicts religion as a normal and good part of films' and TV's central characters' lives are correct that the incidence is much lower in the media than in society as a whole. This is another reminder that it's important to be careful what you pray for. It's Always Sunny in Philadelphia, which runs Thursday nights on the FX Channel at 10 EDT and is available on ITunes, follows the lives of four post-college slackers who run an Irish bar in the title city, and religion, specifically Christianity and more specifically Catholicism, keeps popping up in the characters' lives. The overall tone of the show is fairly spicy, and the humor is both funny and often deliberately edgy, but the treatment of religion is pretty realistic given the characters' situation. It is also both irreverent and basically positive.

The religion the principal characters were taught as a child in working-class Philly often comes up in conversation as they discuss, for example, some of their more shameless schemes. In addition, situations and characters with religious significance arrive on a regular basis. Last Thursday such a character arrived in the form of a priest who had served as the butt of the gang's practical jokes during childhood and adolescence. He provides a conscience figure in response to another of the gang's awful schemes, and then provides a further lesson as one of the group, a young lady on whom he once had a crush, brings disaster on him.

The episode concerns a scheme by the group to make money from donations by Christians after a water stain shaped like the Virgin Mary is discovered in a back room of their bar. Both the scheme and the situation go rapidly downhill from there, and it is all very funny. Yet the wrongness of their quest is never in doubt, and one character's religious qualms about the scheme keeps the story firmly grounded.

In this zany, backhanded way, It's Always Sunny in Philadelphia depicts Christianity in a basically positive way even as it plays mercilessly with its conventions and surfaces.

And as I said, it's definitely funny, as when would-be conman Charlie, pretending to be an evangelist, addresses a small group of pilgrims sitting in the bar:

"Here's a confession: I'm in love with a man. What? I'm in love with a man. A man called God. Does that make me gay? Am I gay for God? You betcha!"

Funny stuff.

From Karnick on Culture.


Tom Van Dyke said...

Swearta G-d, I was gonna do one on Philadelphia, and include that same closing riff. But I thought I might leave it for The Master, STK.

Glad I did.

Also loved their reworking of the old go-to-abortion-rallies-to-pick-up-casual-sex-partners-without-complications.

The womyn turned out to be uninterested in predatory males or men in general---all the action was to be found on the other side with a proper pro-life rap.

But neither was that sufficient, once a certain lack of sincerity was unveiled. And cleverly, too. The pro-life babe was no fool either.

A tight show, and the addition of consummate pro Danny DeVito in the second season looks to only solidify what is a right-hearted attempt to put a mirror to the human condition.

S. T. Karnick said...

Yes, Tom, DeVito adds a certain stability to the scenes in which he appears. Good choice on the producers' part.

The abortion episode you mention was a scream. Both sides were skewered just where they deserve it. And the protest signs were very funny.